The Pool at Carringtons Inn St. Croix
The pool at Carringtons Inn St. Croix is recommended by those who travel for a living. Of the 2 reviews that we tracked, 2 recommended the pool, like Fodor's and Frommer's.
Carringtons Inn St. Croix 
Fodor's
Frommer's
Fodor's "Each room is different, but amenities like four-poster beds, handwoven carpets, and colorful spreads are standard; there are balconies in some rooms, and either sea or pool views"
Frommer's "After inhaling the fab home-cooked breakfasts (French toast, fresh fruit, pancakes), you can lounge around the tiled pool, framed in rounded stone arches and tropical greenery"
