The Restaurant at Osprey Beach Hotel
Osprey Beach Hotel's restaurant is recommended by travel writers. Out of 4 professionals tracked on TripExpert, 2 praised the restaurant, such as Fodor's and Oyster.
Osprey Beach Hotel 
Fodor's
Oyster
Fodor's "There is a full-service restaurant and bar on-site, the fabulous Coral Cafe, spa services, and a dive operator"
Oyster "Sibonne Beach Hotel Grace Bay has a similar laid-back atmosphere and is surrounded by great restaurants and local shops -- however rates tend to be pricier"
