W SantiagovsHotel Magnolia Santiago
Both hotels are rated very highly by expert writers. On balance, W Santiago ranks significantly better than Hotel Magnolia. W Santiago scores 83 with positive reviews from 9 sources including Fodor's, Lonely Planet and Star Service.
W Santiago
Isidora Goyenechea 3000, Santiago 3000, Chile
From $143/night
- Pet Friendly
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Laundry Service
- Concierge
Concierge
"Design is paramount in the ample rooms, too, where floor-to-ceiling windows, fabric-paneled walls, angular furniture, and a plethora of gadgets underscore a masculine sensibility."
Fodor's
"Located in the heart of the fashionable El Golf business and restaurant district, South America's first W hotel opened in mid-2009, setting a new standard of luxury in Santiago." Full review
Travel + Leisure
"In the El Golf district of Chile’s capital, the ebullient Tony Chi (the designer behind the restaurants at Park Hyatt Sydney and Mandarin Oriental New York) is responsible for witty flourishes." Full review
DK Eyewitness
"The most exciting hotel to open in Chile in a decade, W Hotel offers fabulous, cutting-edge decor designed to impress even the most jaded traveler."
Condé Nast Traveler
81.9
"Chi has transformed a whopping chunk of office space with frosted-glass and taffeta partitions, perspective-teasing alpaca ceilings and mirrored walls, and a treasure trove of decorative objects." Full review
Rough Guide
"In an eyecatching skyscraper, The W is a glamorous, achingly hip hotel."
Star Service
"It is the cornerstone of Isidora 3000, a glassy high-rise, mixed-use complex that includes a convention center, boutique office space and high-end shops. " Full review
i
Many rooms (spread through various categories) have windows between the guest rooms and baths, and privacy seekers should avoid these rooms upon check-in.
The Telegraph
8.0
"A veteran of luxury in the Chilean capital...the hotel has aged well. It’s fun, unpretentious, but takes design and service seriously." Full review
Frommer's
"All rooms have views, very large bathrooms, and heaps of electronic bells and whistles." Full review
i
Ask for a west-facing one to see the snow-capped Andes
Lonely Planet
"With three hipper-than-thou eateries and a pair of happening cocktail bars... this W outpost quickly became one of the most prominent landmarks on Santiago's social scene." Full review
Hotel Magnolia Santiago
Paseo Huerfanos 539, Santiago 8320150, Chile
From $280/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Free Breakfast
- Laundry Service
- Concierge
The Telegraph
8.0
"A grand historic house just steps from the old town." Full review
Wallpaper
"The former palatial home of an old Chilean political family has just emerged from a two-year renovation as a 42-room hotel." Full review
Mr & Mrs Smith
"Santiago is famous for many things (ponchos, pisco sours, Pablo Neruda…); and now, Hotel Magnolia, a boutique townhouse stay, is the latest local hero." Full review
i
Before you swing open the polished wooden doors to Hotel Magnolia, be sure to look up: the stone façade of this 1920s grande dame is part of its (considerable) charm.
Fodor's
"It is considered a fine example of fusing old with new, from the old-school facade that is later glassed in, to interior remodels with marble staircases...they offer a good restaurant onsite." Full review
Lonely Planet
Top choice
"No two rooms are exactly alike at this artfully designed boutique hotel, which masterfully intertwines old and new within the confines of a restored 1920s office building." Full review
Michelin Guide
"With contemporary furniture and design flourishes as well — the look is historically informed but far from nostalgic, and the loft-style rooms combine sleek clean lines with warm organic materials." Full review