Map

Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by HiltonvsThe Marker Key West

Both hotels are rated very highly by travel writers. On balance, Casa Marina Key West, A Waldorf Astoria Resort scores significantly higher than The Marker Waterfront Resort. Casa Marina Key West, A Waldorf Astoria Resort scores 90 with endorsements from 10 publications like Oyster, Fodor's and Travel + Leisure.

Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton
9/10
1500 Reynolds St, Key West, FL 33040
From $395/night
  • Pet Friendly
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
show all amenities
Concierge Concierge
"The 311 rooms are now airy and loftlike... rooms in the original building are the best, for their idiosyncratic layout and 15 rooms with large balconies."
Travel + Leisure Travel + Leisure
"Rita Hayworth and Gregory Peck are among the stars who once stayed at this revamped 1920 compound, another product of Henry Flagler's bold vision." Full review
Gayot Gayot
"Boasting Key West's largest private beach (at over 1,000 feet), Casa Marina Resort is a tropical escape just minutes from the island's main attractions."
Frommer's Frommer's
"It’s a great choice for couples and especially families looking for a touch of class along with plenty of activities, upscale amenities, and extras." Full review
Lonely Planet Lonely Planet
"This opulent 311-room hotel was built in the 1920s by railroad magnate Henry Flagler. The lobby still retains its old-world splendor, but the recently renovated rooms are thoroughly modern." Full review
Star Service Star Service
"Casa Marina is certainly the top spot on the island for demanding globetrotters seeking history and luxury." Full review
Fodor's Fodor's
"At any moment, you expect the landed gentry to walk across the oceanfront lawn, just as they did when this 13-acre resort was built back in the 1920s." Full review
The Telegraph The Telegraph
8.0
"Conceived by oil tycoon and South Florida developer Henry Flagler, Casa Marina is one of the island’s most historic and storied resorts." Full review
Jetsetter Jetsetter
"Historic Gatsby-era hotel on the largest private beach on Key West." Full review
Condé Nast Traveler Condé Nast Traveler
"It's got the largest private beach in Key West, making it feel special and secluded." Full review
Show All Reviews
The Marker Key West
7/10
200 William Street, Key West, FL 33040
From $259/night
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Laundry Service
  • Concierge
  • Restaurant
show all amenities
Gayot Gayot
"Sunny luxury accommodations in heart of Key West."
Travel + Leisure Travel + Leisure
"The Marker Waterfront Resort made history in 2014, when it became the first newly built hotel to open in Key West in more than two decades." Full review
The Telegraph The Telegraph
7.0
"Designed to blend into the neighborhood’s historic Bahamian conch cottages and Victorian-style homes, it has an air of under-the-radar cool." Full review
Star Service Star Service
"This is the first built-from-scratch hotel to debut in Key West in nearly two decades. Its arrival signals a sophisticated new boutique option, purpose-built for demanding leisure travelers." Full review

© Tripexpert Inc.