Island HousevsAlexander???s Guest House
Island House and Alexander's Guesthouse are both endorsed by professionals. Overall, Alexander's Guesthouse scores significantly better than Island House. Alexander's Guesthouse ranks #9 in Key West with positive reviews from 4 reviewers like Frommer's, oyster.com and concierge.com.
Island House
1129 Fleming St., Key West, FL 33040
From $334/night
- Pet Friendly
- Bar/Lounge
- Hot Tub
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Laundry Service
Fodor's
"Geared specifically toward gay men, this hotel features a health club, a video lounge, a café and bar, and rooms in historic digs." Full review
Rough Guide
"Men-only, clothing optional resort that’s one of the few remaining cruisey accommodation options in town: there’s a sauna, video room and large pool-cum-sundeck."
Oyster
Upper-middle-range
"Located in historic Key West, Island House is a 34-room boutique designed exclusively for gay men." Full review
Time Out
"Here, amid lush foliage and gingerbread architecture, guests shed their clothes and inhibitions. Bronzed Muscle Marys glisten under the mist spray system on the sun deck or bare all by the pool." Full review
Alexander???s Guest House
1118 Fleming St., Key West, FL 33040
From $395/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Hot Tub
- Free Internet
- Free Breakfast
- Concierge
- Pool
Concierge
"This gay-oriented 17-room B&B is the most stylish on the island and is perfect for those allergic to antiques."
Rough Guide
Star
"The antithesis of most antique-filled B&Bs, this sleek, gay-only spot has white modernist furniture in its large lobby."
Frommer's
"Key West has long ranked among the world’s top destinations for gay and lesbian vacationers." Full review
Oyster
Upper-middle-range
"Alexander's Guesthouse is an intimate, 17-room bed and breakfast designed especially for the LGBT community and supporters." Full review
Time Out
"This is probably the classiest queer guesthouse in town. The gardens are resplendent with banana trees and hibiscus, and the decor approaches boutique standard. There's a nudist sun deck." Full review
Frommer's
"It’s snazzier than ever in looks (bright, clean, and contemporary) and service (friendly and attentive from attractive staffers). There’s a pool and hot tub out back" Full review