Elizabeth Pointe LodgevsAmelia Hotel at the Beach

Both hotels are endorsed by professional reviewers. On balance, Elizabeth Pointe Lodge scores significantly higher than Amelia Hotel at the Beach. Elizabeth Pointe Lodge is ranked #12 in Jacksonville with endorsements from 4 reviews such as Fodor's, Gayot and Lonely Planet.

Elizabeth Pointe Lodge

Tripexpert score:

8/10

Location:98 S. Fletcher Avenue, Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island, FL 32034

Price:

From $219/night

Amenities:

Free Internet
Room Service
Free Breakfast
Concierge
Restaurant
Free Parking

show all amenities

Expert reviews:

Travel + Leisure

"Off the coast of Florida, the Elizabeth Pointe Lodge channels a Nantucket vibe—and has a room configuration for every type of traveler." Full review

Gayot

"This 1890s Nantucket shingle-style inn is a nice alternative on an island filled with Victorian architecture and big resorts. Its gray weathered exterior with clean white trim is somehow comforting."

Fodor's

"Guests at this oceanfront inn .... can't say enough about the impeccable personal service, legendary breakfasts, and enjoyable evening social hour." Full review

Frommer's

"Antiques, reproductions, and other touches lend the 20 rooms in the main building a turn-of-the-20th-century beach-cottage vibe. All have oversize tubs." Full review

Lonely Planet

Top Choice

"Atmosphere oozes from this eccentric yet stylish 1890s Nantucket-shingle-style maritime inn, perched on the ocean, 2 miles from downtown." Full review

Book now

Amelia Hotel at the Beach

Tripexpert score:

7/10

Location:1997 South Fletcher Avenue, Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island, FL 32034