'Tween Waters Island Resort & SpavsManatee Bay Inn

Both hotels are rated highly by those who travel for a living. On balance, 'Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa ranks significantly better than Manatee Bay Inn. 'Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa comes in at 83 with accolades from 3 reviews like Michelin Guide, Fodor's and Lonely Planet.

'Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa

Tripexpert score:

7/10

Location:15951 Captiva Road, Captiva Island, FL 33924

Price:

From $313/night

Amenities:

Pet Friendly
Bar/Lounge
Hot Tub
Free Internet
Free Breakfast
Laundry Service

show all amenities

Expert reviews:

Michelin Guide

"Framed by the gentle gulf surf and calming waters of Pine Island Sound, this timeless, self-contained resort keeps customers coming back for its recreational options and relaxed Old Florida feel."

Fodor's

"Besides its great beach-to-bay location, this inn has historic value and in 2011 was listed in the National Register of Historic Places." Full review

Lonely Planet

Top Choice

"For great resort value on Captiva, choose 'Tween Waters Inn. Rooms are attractive roosts with rattan furnishings, granite counters, rainfall showerheads and Tommy Bahama–style decor."

Frommer's

"The location is great, right across from the Gulf, with a variety of accommodations, a heated Olympic-sized pool, a children's pool, and hot tubs." Full review

Lonely Planet

Top choice

"For great resort value on Captiva, choose ’Tween Waters Inn&*& Rooms are attractive roosts with granite counters, rainfall showerheads and bright, garish decor" Full review

For great resort value on Captiva, choose ’Tween Waters Inn. Rooms are attractive roosts with granite counters, rainfall showerheads and bright, garish decor.

Book now

Manatee Bay Inn