The Restaurant at Plantation Island Resort
Plantation Island Resort's restaurant is endorsed by expert writers. Of the 3 professionals that we tracked, 2 referenced the restaurant, like Oyster and Lonely Planet.
Plantation Island Resort 
Oyster
Lonely Planet
Oyster "Guests can purchase meal plans for the buffet with nightly changing themes or two a la carte restaurants, and there's evening entertainment next to the main bar"
Lonely Planet "Optional full meal plans (adult/child from $132/44) are available, though many guests prefer to spread their meals between the resort eateries and Ananda's Restaurant (mains $25-40) near the airstrip"
