The Pool at Kimpton Charlotte Square
The Roxburghe Hotel, Edinburgh's pool is mentioned by reviewers writing for major publications. Of the 4 reviews that we tracked, 3 praised the pool, like Time Out, Oyster and Star Service.
Kimpton Charlotte Square 
Time Out
Oyster
Star Service
Time Out "Lurking away behind the classical New Town façade (the building is the work of Robert Adam) is a small pool, a gym and 198 bedrooms done up in a style not uncommon in the city: the 19th century meets the 21st"
Oyster "Amenities are superb, including an indoor swimming pool, a brasserie-style restaurant, and a full-service spa"
Star Service "Active guests will appreciate the TechnoGym-equipped fitness center and spa (although the 12-m pool is too small for lap swimming)"
