Map

Malmaison EdinburghvsKildonan Lodge Hotel

Both Malmaison Hotel Edinburgh and Kildonan Lodge Hotel are rated very highly by experts. Overall, Malmaison Hotel Edinburgh is preferred by most professionals compared to Kildonan Lodge Hotel. Malmaison Hotel Edinburgh has a TripExpert Score of 87 with recommendations from 9 sources including Michelin Guide, Frommer's and oyster.com.

Malmaison Edinburgh
8/10
1 Tower Place, Leith, Edinburgh EH6 7BZ, Scotland
From $82/night
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Laundry Service
  • Restaurant
  • Fitness Center
show all amenities
Michelin Guide Michelin Guide
"Impressive former sea mens' mission, set on the quayside; the first of the Malmaison hotels."
Insight Guides Insight Guides
"A superb renovation of Leith's former Seamen's Mission building featuring art deco styling, four-poster beds and a first class restaurant and Parisian bistro."
Rough Guide Rough Guide
"Chic, modern hotel set in the grand old seamen’s hostel just back from the wharf-side."
Star Service Star Service
"Located a 15-minute drive from the center (a long half-hour walk), this hotel cuts a fashionable figure in the longshoreman's part of town." Full review
Frommer's Frommer's
"It's a respectable part of the spruced-up waterfront, its brasserie and bar buzzing, with guests spilling out onto the cobbled street." Full review
i
Opt for a room at the front that overlooks the port
Lonely Planet Lonely Planet
"The stylish, award-winning Malmaison is housed in a 19th-century former Seaman's Mission in Leith."
i
Be sure to ask for a superior room at the front of the hotel, for extra space and a view over the river.
Oyster Oyster
Upscale
"An upscale boutique property with 100 rooms, Malmaison Hotel Edinburgh is housed in a former house of ill repute (yes, a brothel)." Full review
Time Out Time Out
"The Leith hotel that kicked off a hospitality phenomenon." Full review
Fodor's Fodor's
"Once a seamen's hostel, Edinburgh's link in the pioneering boutique hotel chain draws a refined clientele." Full review
The Telegraph The Telegraph
8.0
"Works hard at promoting a sexy image, but is fun and comfortable too, with good-sized rooms, decent food and drink, friendly staff and even some token tartan to remind guests where they are." Full review
Show All Reviews
Kildonan Lodge Hotel
7/10
27 Craigmillar Park, Newington, Edinburgh EH16 5PE, Scotland
From $102/night
  • Pet Friendly
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Free Breakfast
  • Laundry Service
show all amenities
Michelin Guide Michelin Guide
"Spacious and traditionally furnished, with cosy fire-lit drawing room and comfy bedrooms; some with four-posters and jacuzzis."
Lonely Planet Lonely Planet
"An elegant small hotel with a country-house atmosphere, in a residential suburb 3.5km (2.2mi) south of the city centre." Full review
Oyster Oyster
Upper-middle-range
"The 15-room Kildonan Lodge Hotel is a family-owned upper-middle-range property located just outside of Edinburgh's city center and about a seven-minute bus ride to the Royal Mile." Full review

© Tripexpert Inc.