Map

23 Mayfield BOOK DIRECTvsKildonan Lodge Hotel

Both 23 Mayfield and Kildonan Lodge Hotel are recommended by expert reviewers. On balance, 23 Mayfield is the choice of most writers compared to Kildonan Lodge Hotel. 23 Mayfield has a TripExpert Score of 76 with positive reviews from 4 sources like Fodor's, Michelin Guide and oyster.com.

23 Mayfield BOOK DIRECT
7/10
23 Mayfield Gardens, Newington, Edinburgh EH9 2BX, Scotland
From $135/night
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Free Breakfast
  • Free Parking
  • Multilingual
  • Breakfast included
show all amenities
Michelin Guide Michelin Guide
"Lovingly restored Victorian house with a very welcoming, helpful owner and an outdoor hot-tub."
Oyster Oyster
Luxury
"The 23 Mayfieldis a luxury bed-and-breakfast housed in an immaculately presented Victorian villa set about a mile south of Edinburgh's historical center." Full review
Fodor's Fodor's
"A self-styled "boutique guesthouse," 23 Mayfield is a cut above your average B&B."
The Telegraph The Telegraph
9.0
"In this beautifully kept, unassuming Victorian villa you will find candle-light, acres of mahogany panelling, stained glass and bespoke period furniture, with the occasional well-judged modern touch." Full review
Condé Nast Traveler Condé Nast Traveler
"If you’re after an intimate B&B experience—but one that’s a bit elevated—this grand Victorian guest house is perfect." Full review
Kildonan Lodge Hotel
7/10
27 Craigmillar Park, Newington, Edinburgh EH16 5PE, Scotland
From $102/night
  • Pet Friendly
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Free Internet
  • Room Service
  • Free Breakfast
  • Laundry Service
show all amenities
Michelin Guide Michelin Guide
"Spacious and traditionally furnished, with cosy fire-lit drawing room and comfy bedrooms; some with four-posters and jacuzzis."
Lonely Planet Lonely Planet
"An elegant small hotel with a country-house atmosphere, in a residential suburb 3.5km (2.2mi) south of the city centre." Full review
Oyster Oyster
Upper-middle-range
"The 15-room Kildonan Lodge Hotel is a family-owned upper-middle-range property located just outside of Edinburgh's city center and about a seven-minute bus ride to the Royal Mile." Full review

© Tripexpert Inc.