Guana IslandvsSaba Rock Resort
Guana Island and Saba Rock Resort are both rated very highly by professional reviewers writing for major publications. On balance, Guana Island scores slightly higher than Saba Rock Resort. Guana Island ranks #8 in British Virgin Islands with recommendations from 6 reviews like Fodor's, Concierge and Star Service.
Guana Island
Guana Island
From $695/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Free Breakfast
- Restaurant
- Family Friendly
- Tennis Court
Concierge
"Guana is the closest you'll get to a private island without a five-figures-a-day tab: Think a maximum of 36 guests spread over seven beaches."
Fodor's
"Here's a good resort if you want to stroll the hillsides, snorkel around the reefs, swim at its seven beaches, and still enjoy some degree of comfort." Full review
DK Eyewitness
"A mere 30 guests share 850 acres at this remote retreat off Tortola’s north coast. There are seven lovely beaches scattered around the island."
Star Service
"Guests seeking a private island resort who don't want to shell out for Richard Branson's Necker Island might want to consider this private 850-acre island close off the north shore of Tortola." Full review
i
Also worth requesting is Harbour House, which sits atop the hill, and is available with one or two bedrooms.
Jetsetter
"Privately-owned castaway resort with private terraces, miles of nature trails, and a gourmet restaurant." Full review
Hideaway Report
91.0
"Utterly tranquil, mostly undeveloped private island 20 minutes north of Tortola with seaview cottages and villas." Full review
Saba Rock Resort
Virgin Gorda
From $0/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Free Breakfast
- Laundry Service
- Restaurant
- Family Friendly
Fodor's
"Reachable only by a free ferry or by private yacht, this resort on its own tiny cay is perfect for folks who want to mix and mingle with the sailors who drop anchor for the night." Full review
DK Eyewitness
"Saba Rock, a mere speck reached only by boat, has special rates for boaters who need a break from the nautical life."
Frommer's
"This is an idyllic retreat, perched on its own small cay and reached by a free ferry... It is the ultimate escapist retreat." Full review
Lonely Planet
"On a fleck of island just offshore, this charismatic hotel has seven stylish rooms." Full review
Michelin Guide
"A modern nine-room boutique hotel, a surprisingly intimate set of accommodations given all the activity at the waterfront and in the hotel’s open-air restaurant and bar. " Full review