The Pool at El Pescador Resort
The pool at El Pescador Resort is recommended by expert writers. Of the 3 professionals tracked on TripExpert, 2 recommended the pool, like Travel + Leisure and Fodor's.
El Pescador Resort 
Travel + Leisure
Fodor's
Travel + Leisure "A swimming pool fronts an empty beach, and guests feel as if they are the only ones on the entire island"
Fodor's "Adjoining the lodge in two groupings, each with a pool, are deluxe one-, two- and three-bedroom villas"
