The Pool at Caye Casa
Caye Casa's pool is endorsed by professional reviewers. Out of 3 publications that we monitored, 2 acknowledged the pool, including Fodor's and Oyster.
Caye Casa 
Fodor's
Oyster
Fodor's "There's a small pool and a pier"
Oyster "The hotel has a tiny plunge pool and a sandy lounge area, and is across the street from a teensy beach"
