Carlisle Bay AntiguavsThe Inn
Both properties are praised by reviewers writing for major publications. Overall, Carlisle Bay Antigua is the choice of most professionals compared to The Inn at English Harbour. Carlisle Bay Antigua comes in at 94 with praise from 11 reviews such as Afar Magazine, Frommer's and Lonely Planet.
Carlisle Bay Antigua
Old Rd, Saint Mary's, Antigua
From $435/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Free Breakfast
- Laundry Service
- Concierge
Frommer's
"Giving every first-class resort in the Caribbean a serious run for its money is this stunner." Full review
Concierge
"A sister hotel to London's One Aldwych, Carlisle Bay... has been an "it" spot for celebs, rock stars, and those who like to live large since opening in 2003."
Jetsetter
"Dreamy beach escape in Antigua with a pool, splurge-worthy spa, private cinema and yoga pavilion." Full review
i
Afternoon tea, which often includes delectable freshly made shortbread, can be enjoyed on the beach, or just about anyplace you choose.
DK Eyewitness
"With sophisticated luxury on a beautiful southern beach, this resort stresses calm and relaxation."
Fodor's
"This cosmopolitan, boutique sister property of London's trendy One Aldwych hotel daringly eschews everything faux colonial and Creole." Full review
Condé Nast Traveler
83.9
"This 82-suite retreat will leave even the testiest traveler with little room to complain." Full review
Star Service
"Accommodations are hands-down the best-equipped on the island." Full review
The Telegraph
8.0
"Sophisticated, stylish interiors and a fabulously restrained spa. Its isolation means plenty of privacy, but it's within easy access of the English Harbour." Full review
Afar Magazine
"It’s all very restful, but the long list of free non-motorized watersports and the extensive kids' club ensures everyone has plenty to do." Full review
Lonely Planet
"Ultra-posh and contemporary, the Carlisle courts style-conscious global nomads who like to trade the beach lounger for the tennis court, the gym, the trail or the yoga mat." Full review
The Inn
Freeman's bay, St John's, English Harbour, Antigua
From $607/night
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Internet
- Room Service
- Free Breakfast
- Laundry Service
- Concierge
Concierge
"This comfy beachfront inn is a beloved home base for exploring historic English Harbour."
Jetsetter
"When you stay at Inn At English Harbour in English Harbour, you'll be on the beach and minutes from Galleon Beach and Carpenter's Rock Trailhead. This 4.5-star resort is within close..." Full review
Fodor's
"This genteel resort, long a favorite with Brits and the boating set, is ideal for those seeking beachfront accommodations near English Harbour's attractions." Full review
DK Eyewitness
"Situated on Freeman's Bay at the entrance to English Harbour, this comfortable hotel offers beautiful views and outstanding service."
Star Service
"Near the casual, residential Galleon Beach Club, this property remains a quintessential Antiguan resort of the old school that appeals equally to mariners and beachcombers." Full review
Afar Magazine
"The inn is five minutes by water taxi from the center of things at historic Nelson’s Dockyard, but its tucked-away location on a white-sand beach backed by 19 leafy acres...ensures tranquility." Full review
The Telegraph
8.0
"An upmarket boutique hotel occupying a stretch of sand at Galleon Beach." Full review
Frommer's
"Small, serene, and unpretentiously elegant, the Inn at English Harbour has boutique service down to a science" Full review
Lonely Planet
"Enjoy sublime sunsets, cold glass of wine in hand, from the private terrace of your lusciously furnished suite or beach cabaña at this peaceful and romantic retreat from reality" Full review